Supreme Court Reminds Us of the Importance of Voir Dire

A truck driver crashed into Gregory Wagner, causing him serious injury that required amputation of both legs. Warner sued the driver for negligence and invoked his constitutional right to a jury trial. During voir dire (jury selection), Wagner’s lawyer asked the prospective jurors if they would have trouble being fair and impartial. They all said no, but one juror was not telling the truth. The falsehood was discovered after the verdict in favor of the defendant was rendered, at which point Wagner’s lawyer asked for a new trial.

The Supreme Court rejected Wagner’s request for a new trial and even prevented him from inquiring into the validity of the verdict—despite the evidence of the juror’s dishonesty. The Court was concerned that allowing such an inquiry would undermine the goals of “promoting the finality of verdicts and insulating the jury from outside influences.” And what about the right to a jury that is fair and impartial? The Court’s answer was that voir dire is the means of protecting that right.

Although voir dire was unsuccessful in this case, the Court’s decision reminds us just how crucial it is for trial lawyers to execute voir dire effectively so as to ferret out bias and ensure that the verdict the jury renders is truly fair and impartial.

Categories

    Our Family will be Forever Grateful!

    - Tim S.

    Attorney Tor and the whole team at Spangenberg Shibley & Liber, including the receptionist, made me feel welcome, comforted, and confident throughout my case. They showed me respect and kindness from start to finish.

    - Zandra S.

    I was feeling uncertain but after I met with Nick I felt at ease & confident. Communication was great, I was constantly informed and everyone was genuine & compassionate.

    - Sonja S.

    Coming in, we were unsure if we had a case. After meeting with Peter Brodhead, we were very confident with him. I was always comfortable because everyone was professional and friendly.

    - Elaine B.

    I liked the professionalism, efficiency, and thoroughness of your team efforts. I would like Sheila Schebek recognized for her knowledge of account details as quickly as I presented questions. She provided confidence and security in all matters.

    - John S.
/

Put Award-Winning
Trial Lawyers On Your Side

Contact Our Team for a Free & Confidential Case Evaluation
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.