Supreme Court Allows Immediate Appeal of MDL Judge’s Ruling

Home  /  Recent News  /  Supreme Court Allows Immediate Appeal of MDL Judge’s Ruling
Supreme Court Allows Immediate Appeal of MDL Judge’s Ruling

Feb 02, 2015

  |  

General

To improve the efficiency of the federal courts (whose dockets are overwhelming) Congress created a procedural device back in the 1960s called Multidistrict Litigation (“MDL”). The device allows a large number of related cases filed in multiple federal districts to be consolidated before a single federal judge. (Imagine, for example, a thousand product-liability cases filed by a thousand individuals against a single drug manufacturer in fifty federal courts.) The device permits one judge to coordinate discovery, rule on pretrial matters, and even hold bellwether (or representative) trials. Judges and lawyers appreciate the efficiency and consistency of rulings MDLs promote.

The Supreme Court recently issued an opinion on a matter of consequence to MDLs. An MDL was created to consolidate 60 cases involving allegations that several banks conspired to violate antitrust laws. The MDL judge granted the banks’ motion to dismiss one of the cases on the ground that the plaintiffs had suffered no antitrust injury. The other cases remained before the MDL judge. The question was whether the plaintiffs whose case was dismissed could file an appeal immediately even though the MDL continued apace.

The justices unanimously said yes, holding that the right to appeal arises when an MDL judge dismisses a case, not when the entire MDL proceeding ends.

This was a sensible ruling. Although MDLs promote efficiency, they sometimes last for years. It would be unfair to require a plaintiff whose case is dismissed in the early stages of an MDL to wait years before filing an appeal (which itself may take more than two years to resolve); that would risk a “denial of justice through delay.” The Court’s opinion can be found here.

Commitment. Integrity. Results.

It’s not just a motto. We’ll stand by your side and fight for your rights.

History of Excellence

We have been helping individuals since 1946 and have secured over a billion dollars on behalf of our clients.

Commitment

We take our clients’ struggles personally. We fight tirelessly for those we represent and never back down when justice is on the line.

Integrity

We believe in doing what is right, not what is easy. We stand by our clients, our word, and our principles.

Results

We measure success by the difference we make, holding wrongdoers accountable, changing lives, and delivering the justice our clients deserve.

spangberg footer image

Put Our 80 Years of
Trial Excellence
to Work for You.

Spangenberg Shibley & Liber offers free, no-obligation
consultations so you have nothing to lose!