Prolonging a Traffic Stop for a Dog Sniff Violates the Constitution

Home  /  Recent News  /  Prolonging a Traffic Stop for a Dog Sniff Violates the Constitution
Prolonging a Traffic Stop for a Dog Sniff Violates the Constitution

Apr 23, 2015

  |  

General

Dennys Rodriguez was pulled over by highway patrol for veering onto the shoulder, which is unlawful in Nebraska. The officer checked Rodriguez’s license, registration, insurance, and for outstanding warrants. He issued a warning and gave back the documents—but then asked permission to walk his drug-sniffing K-9 around the car. Rodriguez said no. The officer nevertheless took his dog around the car; the dog alerted to the presence of drugs. A search of the car turned up a bag of methamphetamine.

The Supreme Court ruled that the drug sniff violated the Fourth Amendment. The Court said that a traffic stop may last only as long as necessary to accomplish the mission of the stop. The officers mission when he pulled over Rodriguez was to address the traffic infraction. Once he accomplished that objective, the mission was over, and so was his authority to detain Rodriguez. The officer’s prolonging the stop to lead his dog around the car therefore violated Rodriguez’s Fourth Amendment right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures.

This ruling is somewhat unusual, as the trend in recent years has been for the Supreme Court to rule against individuals claiming Fourth Amendment violations.

Commitment. Integrity. Results.

It’s not just a motto. We’ll stand by your side and fight for your rights.

History of Excellence

We have been helping individuals since 1946 and have secured over a billion dollars on behalf of our clients.

Commitment

We take our clients’ struggles personally. We fight tirelessly for those we represent and never back down when justice is on the line.

Integrity

We believe in doing what is right, not what is easy. We stand by our clients, our word, and our principles.

Results

We measure success by the difference we make, holding wrongdoers accountable, changing lives, and delivering the justice our clients deserve.

spangberg footer image

Put Our 80 Years of
Trial Excellence
to Work for You.

Spangenberg Shibley & Liber offers free, no-obligation
consultations so you have nothing to lose!